"This is perfect for teen gamers and readers who are fans of Jesse Andrews and John Green. An excellent purchase for YA shelves."

– School Library Journal, May 1, 2016

“A plugged-in young adult comedy about the pain of unplugging… perfect for teen gamers and readers who are fans of Jesse Andrews and John Green.”

– School Library Journal

“Heidicker’s debut crackles with twitchy energy… this is a fun, absurdist romp through gaming culture, populated by zany characters and a quest narrative worthy of its own game.”

– Booklist

“Where the novel really shines is in Jaxon's interactions—as a white, upper-middle-class boy—with campmates who are diverse in terms of both ethnicity and sexuality, and who challenge some of his preexisting assumptions. In confronting Jaxon's privilege and complicated family history, the book eschews easy answers for a more authentic ending that promises that the work of self-improvement is ongoing and difficult.”

– Publishers Weekly

“This novel is reminiscent of Vizzini’s The Other Normals or Yang’s Level Up. Notably (and happily), however, it avoids the typical game-blaming and recognizes excessive time online as the symptom, not the cause, of these kids’ problems…Gamer readers will flock to this novel and fall in love with its insider jokes, game-allusions, and snarky attitude."

– The Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books

"As a game-versus-life story, this novel is reminiscent of Vizzini’s The Other Normals or Yang’s Level Up. Notably (and happily), however, it avoids the typical game-blaming and recognizes excessive time online as the symptom, not the cause, of these kids’ problems."

– BCCB, June 2016