For Alex and Molly, the last three years of their love story have felt like Christmas every day, full of shared kisses, study dates, and sickeningly cute couple selfies. So what better way to celebrate winter break of their senior year than a romantic holiday getaway in a town right out of a Christmas-card?

Aside from sampling all the holiday cheer the festive town of Barnwich has to offer, Alex and Molly have an important mission this weekend: help their friend Cora get her crush May to fall for her. But in between ice skating, snowball fights, and matchmaking schemes, it becomes obvious that both of them have another self-imposed mission this weekend: to not reveal the huge secrets they’re each keeping from one another. Secrets about their post-college plans that just might threaten to tear them apart.

Will these two be able to help Cora get the girl and keep theirs—or will this be the last Christmas of Alex and Molly’s love story?